Back to search

Picking Sides

2.1.0

by Florens

5 downloads

1 favourite

FullCarousel

My take on a beginner+ script, built around the Kazali as an alternative to the usual Imp.

Storytelling hints

In Kazali games you will usually want to go under or over the base count, to make it possible to find demon type by solving outsider count. If the Kazali replaces one too many outsiders during setup, you can always still slap the Drunk on a townsfolk.

The Spy should never register as good to the Alsaahir: a correct guess that includes the Spy wins.

The Cast

The stars of the show, and the reason for the script's name, are the Kazali, Alsaahir and Ogre. Below is a list of each character on the script, and why I put them there.

Townsfolk

  • Knight: Some soft start-knowing info that might give an Alsaahir an early lead.
  • Noble: Simple start-knowing info that points at specific evil candidates. Meant as an analog to TB's Investigator.
  • Librarian: Some much-needed info on outsiders, in a game where the outsider count can be arbitrary.
  • Shugenja: Gives positional info about evil players. Chosen over Clockmaker or Chef, because a Kazali could "game" those with their minion picks.
  • Empath: Standard-issue ongoing alignment reads.
  • Fortune Teller: Standard-issue each-night demon-finder.
  • Oracle: Simple each-night info. Can catch an Imp starpass, or read an evil-turned Ogre (or Cannibal-Ogre).
  • Monk: Straightforward protection.
  • Alsaahir: Ongoing info that fuels world-building discussions a bit. Also interesting combined with Kazali, because it forces you to think about which minions a theoretical demon might have chosen.
  • Seamstress: No good reason other than that it felt beginner-friendly enough.
  • Slayer: It slays.
  • Cannibal: Chosen as a more chaotic variant of Undertaker. It gets interesting when they eat an Ogre, or someone bluffing as it.
  • Sage: The one that should scare demons, chosen as a direct replacement for TB's Ravenkeeper.
  • Mayor: I needed a 14th townsfolk, because in 15-player Kazali games with a Drunk, there would not be enough unique characters for 3 demon bluffs. And Mayor is also just a very good demon bluff.

Outsiders

  • Ogre: One of the least hated outsiders, and it fit the script name too well to leave it out.
  • Drunk: Some much-needed misinfo.
  • Saint: The ultimate demon bluff.
  • Zealot: A plain and simple alternative to the Butler. Helps indecisive towns speed up executions.

Minions

  • Poisoner: It poisons.
  • Spy: The TB grim peeker. Its misinfo only ever points at one evil player, which feels easier than the Widow's poison.
  • Marionette: Easy to understand, and adds another source of misinfo. I also just think it's cool with Kazali, even if it's not a popular pick.
  • Scarlet Woman: Demon mobility for the Kazali, and a backup for the Imp's starpass.

Demons

  • Imp: The familiar TB demon.
  • Kazali: Beginner demons can pick players they consider more experienced, or choose minions they are most comfortable with (like the Scarlet Woman escape hatch). Or just choose their best friends!

Self-imposed rules

These are some general rules I stuck by for building the script.

  • No madness
  • No misregistration, except the Spy (and never towards the Alsaahir)
  • No vote/nomination tracking (Town Crier, Flower Girl)

Changelog

2.1.0 - 2026-11-14

  • Replaced Philosopher with Empath: Philosopher requires a new player to read the entire script, and could lead to +2 evils with Ogre. We also needed a bit more ongoing info.
  • Replaced Widow with Spy: an attempt to reduce droison sources. The Spy's misregistration only covers itself, while the Widow's poison could more effectively stop mechanical abilities or cover the demon.

2.0.0 - 2026-11-10

  • Added Imp: outsider count is meaningful again, and starpasses make the Oracle more interesting.
  • Replaced Gambler with Seamstress: evil couldn't really bluff Gambler.

1.4.0 - 2026-11-10

  • Replaced Devil's Advocate with Marionette: for the same reason as replacing Assassin below.
  • Replaced Tea Lady with Monk: it's the more logical protection role now that Devil's Advocate is gone.

1.3.0 - 2026-11-07

  • Replaced Tinker with Zealot: Tinker wasn't serving much use anymore, since it can no longer be used to cover a Monk protection. Zealot is an easy to understand role as well.
  • Replaced Assassin with Widow: Assassin can be a bit rough for good on a beginner script (-1 execution), especially on low player counts. Widow instead brings in a grim peeker and another chance for poisoning.

1.2.0 - 2026-10-29

  • Replaced Steward with Knight: it's a bit less hard-confirming
  • Replaced Pixie with Librarian and Mutant with Saint: No more madness on a "beginner" script, and also a bit less hard-confirming
  • Replaced Monk with Oracle: Monk next to Tea Lady was a potential soft-lock

1.1.0 - 2026-10-28

  • Added Mayor for a total of 14 townsfolk: in a 15-player game, there were not enough characters for the bluffs (that weren't previously seen by a minion). It's also just a good demon bluff.
  • Replaced Clockmaker with Shugenja: with Kazali, the Clockmaker's number is entirely in the demon's hands. This forces them to make specific minion picks, and the best minion placing might not be intuitive for new players.
Picking Sides by Florens - Ravenswood Archive